Political News

Votes on public pensions fuel calls for statewide change

Posted 7 years 298 days ago ago by newspaper editor    2 Comments  0 Likes Like Dislike

The State Worker: Votes on public pensions fuel calls for statewide change

By Jon Ortiz June 7, 2012

Tuesday's landslide pension reform votes in San Diego and San Jose were just the early tremors in what could become a public pension earthquake by the end of this month.

The big question: What does this mean for pension reform legislation at the Capitol?

Gov. Jerry Brown, who has floated a 12-point pension reform plan, told a San Francisco Chronicle reporter on Wednesday that the vote in liberal San Jose was "a very powerful signal" that pension reform is "an imperative" that he's putting "at the top of the agenda." Brown thinks pension reform will make his tax initiative more palatable to voters in November, although he hasn't talked about it much until now.

Pension reformers hailed the news that supermajorities in two of California's biggest cities embraced pension benefit rollbacks for current employees – a legally murky idea – and not just future workers. It's a sign, they said, that the public is tired of feeding pensions while public services go to seed.

"To me, it was a brutal, brutal night for unions and the status quo," said Republican strategist Aaron McLear, referring also to a failed effort to recall Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker in a race considered a referendum on his decision to take on public employee unions.

Meanwhile, the unions downplayed Tuesday's results. Dave Low, chairman of union coalition Californians for Retirement Security, noted San Diego's Proposition B supporters outspent their opponents 8 to 1.

Why the disparity? The unions saw the polling and didn't want to spend on a lost cause. They're also saving up for an expected donnybrook over a November ballot measure that ends payroll deductions for political spending, the unions' primary source of funding.

They also figured the real fight will be in the courts. Unions filed lawsuits on Wednesday to block the San Jose reforms. "And there are more to come," said attorney Harvey Leiderman, who represents two of San Jose's civic retirement boards.

Headlines in the next few weeks will further crank up the volume on calls for public pension changes.

Barring an epic market recovery this month, CalPERS, the nation's biggest public pension fund, will close its fiscal year on June 30 with a loss. It ended last year with $237 billion in assets, $13 billion more than its value when the markets closed Monday.

On July 1, pension costs for school districts in CalPERS will go up a collective $137 million per year. That's because the fund decided in March to lower its investment return forecast from 7.75 percent to 7.5 percent. Cities, counties and other municipal agencies will face higher costs next year.

Meanwhile, a special committee of lawmakers is working on what Senate President Pro Tem Darrell Steinberg promises will be "substantive" pension legislation. Tuesday's votes, Brown's re-engagement and the rough pension fund waters ahead are converging at a crucial time in the public debate.


You need to login to comment.

  • Watercolor Artist 7 years 279 days ago
    We need to get Dan Lundgren out of office. When it comes time to vote, we need a change of political figures. Dan has tried to give away our retiree pension fund out to the public. He has tried to take away all the money from both CalPERS and CalSTRS. He needs to be out of office and we need to put someone else in. We need to look close at how the legislators veto and veto out those who veto against us. This is the only way to protect our pension and State jobs.

  • Ed Huey 7 years 297 days ago
    Now, more than ever, it is essential that we draw the distinction between "public employees" and STATE employees. At the local level, cities like San Diego and San Jose saw their pension costs triple over 10 years, so that pensions required over a quarter of their annual operating budget. However, STATE pension expense is only 3% of the total state budget. We must be on guard to keep from being "tarred with the same brush" as cities and counties deal with their pension expenses.

CalPERS Pension Buck

CSR is the largest, most experienced organization exclusively representing state government retirees!


Find Us

California State Retirees
3000 Advantage Way Sacramento, CA 95834

Contact Us

Fax 916.326.4201

Follow Us


Hear From Us